Bush Follies Brought Tudors to Broadway

With a new season of Showtime’s The Tudors coming up and Barack Obama now bogged down by controversial plans for Afghanistan, it seems appropriate to reflect on a recent trend that graced the Broadway stage over the past couple years. George W. Bush’s reign got Americans riled up, doubting their Commander-in-Chief’s decision-making abilities and crying for “change.” Hope is a theme on display in the current Broadway revival of Ragtime — possibly a little late to the game seeing how Obama’s grace period is over — but looking back at the recent cultural landscape, outrage and fear were strong themes playing out on stage throughout 2008-2009.


Surveying some of Broadway’s best offerings over the last couple years, as well as a quick glance at prime-time television programming, one common storyline jumps out. King Henry VIII and all of the Tudors-related atrocities have seen a prominent revival, most recently with the recently updated play Mary Stuart, along with the recent Broadway revival of A Man for All Seasons and the latest season of The Tudors. Three politically weighty stories, each attacking another aspect of the Tudor’s reign in Britain. American audiences have embraced these productions, on some level, because of a fury over the Bush throne, built up and managed not unlike a royal bloodline.

When London’s Donmar Warehouse staged a newly updated production of Friedrich Schiller’s Mary Stuart in 2005, British audiences had an opportunity to relate not only to the shrewd railings against their own royal history, but also their prime minister Tony Blair‘s link with Bush. American audiences then had a chance to embrace the tale of Mary Queen of Scots and her archrival Elizabeth I, as the London production transferred with much fanfare to Broadway’s Broadhurst Theatre, having opened in April of this year. Without a storied Monarch to draw comparisons with, the onus falls directly onto the shoulders of the Bush administration when justifying our recent interest in the Tudors lot. Peter Oswald’s adaptation of Mary Stuart provided an exciting look into an epic political battle between two of history’s most power hungry leaders.

After King Henry VIII died, his crown was passed down to his sole son, but only briefly, as within a few years King Edward VI would succumb to a grave illness. Enter Queen Mary I and then Elizabeth I, all Henry’s descendents. But Elizabeth’s throne was not without dispute, especially from cousin Mary Stuart and her loyal followers. Religion was a main proponent of their quarrel, with Mary advocating the return of Catholicism in England. Nothing like a good ideological dispute to send shivers down a country’s spine.


America often faces this conflict, as was the case with Bush and his belief that he was doing divine work, telling the Palestinian Prime Minister in 2005 that he was “driven with a mission from God.” Such rhetoric is sketchy businesses in a country made up of so many varied religions, along with a growing population of agnostic people.  After all, there is a guiding principle of church and state being separated in America, at least in theory, although that hasn’t lived up to all the hype.

The echoes of America’s hatred towards Bush rang throughout Mary Stuart, which is rather uncanny seeing how it was first staged in 1800. In an explosive scene with Mary, the lady breaks into a carnal outburst, shouting to the heavens that her cousin Elizabeth is undeserving having usurped the position without the graces of God. She screams, “The throne of England is desecrated by a bastard, and the noble people of the British Isles robbed by a simple trick. If right was honoured you would be sprawling in the dust before me, because I am your Queen.” An argument many would later make towards our president who was questionably anointed to the highest position in the land, not by election, rather by the Supreme Court. The sense of fury from those on opposite sides of the political spectrum was the same in 1587, when the play is set. Mary and Elizabeth’s rival was so hotly debated that it draws many parallels to the divisive nature of the elections between Bush and Gore then later John Kerry.

Despite a lackluster appearance on Broadway last year, the Roundabout Theatre production of Robert Bolt’s play A Man For All Seasons must credit the same sense of American outrage that Mary Stuart thrived on. Looking back to Henry VIII, an often mirror political image of Bush, this work focuses on the persecution of Saint Thomas More by the King of England.  “You’re either with us, or against us.” Ring any bells? The stuff of horror when it came to Medieval England, thanks to an execution happy ruler.

Thomas Cromwell plays a rather large role in A Man For All Seasons, as he often did Henry’s dirty work, much like a more recent second in command. His utter contempt for More’s religious allegiance to the Pope, an ideal Cromwell and Henry fought tirelessly to rid from England, sparked a vendetta that ultimately caused More to lose his head. The construct of Cromwell’s argument is eerily reminiscent of the Bush administration’s using false evidence to launch America into war. When Henry’s chief minister realizes More is not actually guilty of any crime, he decides to manipulate the truth.  “It must be done by law,” Cromwell tells Richard Rich when concocting a way to seal More’s fate. “It’s just a matter of finding the right law. Or making one.” Perhaps the beginnings of the now ridiculed Patriot Act. Leaders abusing power in order to win an argument turns out to be an age-old story.

Mary Stuart easily stands on its own, not only for the socially relevant storyline, but also for its leading ladies, Janet McTeer as Mary and Harriet Walter as Elizabeth. Broadway often tries at the game of Bush bashing, more recently with a tongue-in-cheek style such as Avenue Q making colorful remarks or highly comical as is done through talk of stripping away minority’s rights in Wicked. Such fodder is usually entertaining, but having a chance to unearth a play that discovered a newfound relevance after a few decades of sitting on the shelf allowed for a year of continuing the political conversation.

Published by The Huffington Post on December 28, 2009.


  1. While this subject can be very touchy for most people, my opinion is that there has to be a middle or regularground that we all can find. I do appreciate that youve added relevant and clevercommentary here though. Thank you!

  2. My brother and I really have to thank you, this was very good to read!

  3. Good, thanks! Maybe you can do a follow up post about it?

  4. This is a wonderful piece of content, I discovered your web site doing research bing for a similar subject matter and came to this. I couldnt discover to much additional details on this piece of writing, so it was great to locate this one. I probably will end up being returning to check out some other articles that you have another time.

  5. This was worth reading, where did you get this info?

  6. Artykuly ciekawe, ja poprawil bym troche grafike i bylby idealny blog

  7. Hello,The Motif of your blog is very Suit to me, I hope more exchanges with you this Topic.

  8. Interesting. It’s the same here in Wellington. Can be remarkably amusing, but that’s how it is in the 21st century.

  9. Heading to spread the word about your blog to all my subscibers. Thanks so significantly.

  10. anyone saying that the web is full of crap and nonsense information, they better read your blog and see who is talking non sense. keep on posting.

  11. Will be blogengine much better than wp in some way? Needs to be which is more and more popluar these days.

  12. Ta! I prefer to use technical analysis for my Forex trades although I also keep a watchful eye on the news side of things so that I don’t get pipped out on my trades.

  13. I was extremely delighted to find this website.I needed to thank you with regard to a great read!! I definitely loved each and every little bit of it and I’ve you book-marked to look at other stuff you write.

  14. Totally, it took me approximately 40 minutes to find this fantastic post. Thanks.

  15. Well written post, well researched and useful for me in the future.

  16. I wanted to express Thank You for providing this information, youre doing a great job with the site…

  17. Why is it that the content reminds me of another very much the same engineered so Someone said in other places?

  18. Resources just like the one you described right here will be incredibly useful with me! I will submit a website link to this page on my web site. I’m certain my visitors will discover that extremely useful.

  19. I love what youve done with the website.. Found the solution I was searching for.. Are you able to pls deliver a lot more details about this topic??? BTW your internet site is first-class. Sincerely..

  20. I thought it was gonna be some boring outdated post, however it compensated for my time. I’ll post a hyperlink for this particular page on our blog. I am certain my very own visitors will discover which very helpful.

  21. I want to thnkx for the time you earn in writing this blogpost. I am hoping the same best product of your stuff later on as well. Actually your creative writing skill has inspired me to start my own blog now. Truly the blogging is spreading its wings quickly. Your article is a fine illustration of it.

  22. When historical opinions and rules of existence are taken away, the loss are not able to quite possibly be approximated. From that minute we now have no compass to govern us, nor can we know distinctly to what port to steer.

  23. Strange this post is totaly irrelevant for the search query I entered inside the search engines however it was on the first page. Man, I must say i loved reading your blogpost. You have convinced me a subscription for your blog, but how can i find the Feed?

  24. Good info, many thank you to the author. It is incomprehensible to me now, but in general, the particular usefulness and importance is overpowering. Thanks again and good luck!

  25. TY for blogging this, it was quite handy and helped a ton… Great theme, did you are making it by yourself? Looks superb! Facinating post to check on this awesome blog. Never write any replies but now i just did not resist ..

  26. Awesome website! Your style is so fresh in comparison with most other people. Thanks for posting whenever you have the opportunity to, I will be sure to save your website!s

  27. Good post, thanks. I just agreed to your site feed. I appreciate your time spent on this article, bad i had to spend this long to find it but reported by users good quality is hard to locate. Keep it up.

  28. When I view your Feed it throws up a webpage of weird text, is the malfunction on my side?

  29. Thanks for taking the time to talk about this, I feel fervently about this and I take pleasure in learning about this topic. Please, as you gain information, please update this blog with more information. I have found it very useful. There have to be charging stations everywhere.

  30. this is insane… i remember when the earthquake happened and there was a lot of money raised to help those get back on their feet. what’s happening now? nothing http://www.rokettubeee.org “porno izle” has changed and “rokettube” everyone seems to ignore it

  31. TY a ton for writing this, it was unbelieveably informative and helped me a great deal. I had been searching for crucial home elevators this subject. The info was important as I’m going to launch my very own portal.

  32. I’ve wanted to write something like this on my webpage and this has given me a concept. Keep working, nice post! This was the data I needed to know.

  33. I enjoy reading your blog to the component that you’ll be able to on a regular basis get us neat and condition things, I feel i need to a minimum of thank you in your efforts.

  34. Thank you very much for this article. Looking forward to another one.

  35. Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d really like to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please shoot me an email if interested. Thank you!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.